Forget everything else for a minute and let’s talk about that feeling. You know the one. Maybe it’s been a long day, maybe it’s cold out and maybe the world just feels a bit much… and all you crave, deep down in your soul, is something warm, cheesy, carby, and utterly, blissfully comforting. Doesn’t matter if you’re in Casablanca or Cardiff, that feeling is universal, right? Well, my friend, the answer – the only answer sometimes – is the Mary Berry macaroni cheese recipe.

Honestly, I almost feel like I shouldn’t share this, like it’s my secret weapon for happiness. But it’s too good not to. This isn’t just food; it’s therapy in a baking dish. Mary Berry, bless her, just nailed it. It’s straightforward enough that you can practically make it with your eyes half-closed after a nightmare day, but it tastes like you spent hours slaving over a hot stove (you didn’t, obviously). It’s creamy beyond belief, ridiculously cheesy, and has that perfect crispy top… sigh. Just thinking about it makes me hungry.

Seriously, if you think making a proper cheese sauce is scary, let Mama Mary (and me!) hold your hand. It’s genuinely not hard, pinky promise.

So, What Do We Need for This Bowl of Pure Joy?

Alright, raid your cupboards and fridge. You’ll need:

Pasta: Macaroni is the OG, the classic. Little tubes of perfection designed to scoop up maximum sauce. But look, if you’ve only got fusilli or penne, don’t stress! Use it! Life’s too short to worry about pasta shapes sometimes. (GF? Use GF pasta, obviously!)
Cheese: Right, sermon time. Please, I beg you, buy a block of decent sharp Cheddar. That pre-grated stuff in bags just isn’t the same – it has stuff in it to stop it clumping, which means it doesn’t melt as dreamily. Get a block, find your grater (yes, that rusty one at the back of the drawer will do), and put in thirty seconds of arm work. You will thank me later when you taste that glorious, smooth, properly cheesy sauce. It’s the heart of the Mary Berry macaroni cheese recipe!
Butter: A knob of butter. Simple.
Flour: Just plain flour, for thickening our sauce into velvety goodness.
Milk: Okay, controversial opinion maybe, but use whole milk if you possibly can. Go on. Treat yourself. It makes it so much creamier. Semi-skimmed is fine, but full-fat is where the magic is. (Plant-based? Oat milk is pretty great here!)
Mustard Powder: Tiny bit! TRUST. It’s not about tasting mustardy; it’s like a backstage crew member for the cheese, pushing it into the spotlight. Enhances the cheesy flavour like you wouldn’t believe.
Nutmeg: Just a teeny grating. Like, wave the nutmeg over the pan once. Adds a little mysterious warmth. Don’t skip it!
Breadcrumbs: Crucial for the crunchy lid! Panko gives insane crunch, but any breadcrumbs will do. Even blitzing up a slice of slightly stale bread works wonders!
Anything Else?: Look, if you want to throw in some cooked bacon, some peas, maybe some leftover roasted veg? Go for it. Make it your own! But the basic version is perfection.

Okay, Let’s Do This Thing: Operation Comfort Food is GO!

Deep breaths. You’ve got this. It’s easy:

Pasta Wrangling: Big pan, lots of water, good pinch of salt (don’t be shy!). Boil it. Add pasta. Cook till al dente – still got a tiny bit of bite, remember? We don’t want floppy, sad pasta. Drain it really well. Set aside.
The Sauce Ritual: Melt your butter in another pan. Medium heat. Whisk in the flour, cook for a minute while stirring – gets rid of that raw taste. Now, the milk. Add it SLOWLY. Bit by bit. Whisking like you mean it the entire time. This is the key to smooth, non-lumpy sauce! Keep going till all the milk is in and it’s looking thick and gorgeous. Turn the heat right down – like, super low. Now, the glorious moment: add the CHEESE (you grated it, right? Right?), the mustard powder, the nutmeg whisper. Stir gently until melted, smooth, and smelling ridiculously good. Try not to just eat the sauce with a spoon right now (okay, maybe have one tiny taste…).
The Big Cheesy Hug: Pour that incredible sauce over your drained pasta. Gently stir it all together. Make sure every single piece of pasta is lovingly coated. No pasta left behind!
Get Ready for Glory: Scrape the whole beautiful mess into an ovenproof dish. Doesn’t need to be fancy. Sprinkle the breadcrumbs all over the top. Be generous! Now, into a hot oven (190°C/375°F) for 20-25 minutes. You’re listening for the bubble, watching for the golden-brown top. That smell filling your kitchen? That’s pure happiness baking.

Serving This Masterpiece

Honestly? Best served piping hot, maybe letting it sit for just a couple of minutes so you don’t completely incinerate your mouth (we’ve all been there). Scoop generous portions. A simple green salad on the side makes you feel slightly virtuous, but is entirely optional. Sometimes, you just need the mac.

Leftovers? (Are You Joking?)

If, by some strange magic, you have leftovers: cover, fridge, good for a couple of days. Reheat gently. Freezing is also an option, believe it or not! Thaw properly before reheating. It’s a gift to your future self.

Seriously Though…

This Mary Berry macaroni cheese recipe is more than just a recipe. It’s a hug. It’s reliable. It’s delicious. It’s proof that sometimes the simplest things are the absolute best. Make it. Eat it. Feel better about everything. You won’t regret it.

Recipes You May Like

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Spread the love